Three years on Manchester City still waiting as 115-charge case drags into limbo

Three years after the Premier League charged Manchester City with 115 alleged breaches of its financial rules, the most significant regulatory case in English football remains unresolved.

The charges, issued on 6 February 2023, relate to alleged breaches spanning nine years from 2009 to 2018, with the City accused of misrepresenting sponsorship revenue and failing to fully cooperate with league investigations. 

While the scale of the case was always expected to require a lot of time, the absence of a verdict has become increasingly a defining feature of the process rather than a by-product.

An independent commission heard evidence and legal submissions between September and December 2024, but is still considering its verdict, with no timetable set for a final decision.

Michael Regan - UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images

Why the case has taken so long

The delay is largely a function of scale and the number of charges, which some reports suggest may be closer to 130 once sub-clauses are accounted for, making this an unprecedented case in Premier League history.

Each allegation requires individual examination, supported by extensive financial records, witness testimony and legal argument. 

Unlike profit and sustainability cases, which operate under fixed procedural timelines, this commission was not bound by a formal deadline.

Legal experts have repeatedly stressed that cases of this magnitude are inherently slow-moving, particularly when both sides are well-resourced and determined to contest every point.

That reality explains the pace, but it has not softened frustration among clubs, supporters and observers, particularly as the case now spans multiple seasons with no clear endpoint.

Getty Images

Uncertainty that now cuts beyond Manchester City

Manchester City have continued to operate largely unaffected on the pitch, competing for titles and recruiting heavily, with Pep Guardiola repeatedly expressing confidence in the club’s position.

For the Premier League, however, the prolonged wait has created a broader problem. Competitive outcomes across several seasons now exist under a cloud of conditionality, with no clarity on whether past or future results could yet be altered.

Rival clubs are left to speculate about points deductions, fines or more severe sanctions, while supporters are asked to accept a title race and league table that may still be subject to retrospective scrutiny.

The longer the silence continues, the harder it becomes for any eventual verdict to restore trust in the system that produced it.