What can Manchester United expect from caretaker Carrick?

Michael Carrick’s return to Old Trafford as caretaker manager invites a familiar question: what does his coaching identity actually look like when stripped of sentiment?

United supporters remember the elegance of the player and the calm authority of his brief interim spell in 2021, but Carrick the coach is best understood through his work at Middlesbrough and the tactical education he received under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.

At Boro, Carrick established himself as a control-first coach. His teams prioritised possession, short build-up and positional discipline, often taking the form of a 4-2-3-1.

Middlesbrough were patient rather than passive. Circulation was used to draw pressure, not simply to dominate the ball. The defining feature was structure. Carrick wanted spacing between lines, clear passing angles and minimal chaos in defensive transition. It was not rigid, but it was deliberate.

That contrasts with his time under Solskjaer at United, where Carrick was heavily involved in match preparation and midfield organisation. United’s best moments in that era came when they balanced transition threat with rest defence, protecting central spaces while allowing attacking talent to improvise. Carrick has seemingly always leaned toward order before expression, believing freedom works best when roles are clearly defined.

At United now, that instinct would likely shape how he uses Bruno Fernandes. Rather than an all-action free radical, Fernandes may be asked to operate more consistently between the lines, receiving on the half-turn and dictating tempo rather than chasing moments.

(C)Getty Images

Carrick has previously shown a willingness to rein in risk if it improves collective control, something Fernandes has occasionally lacked in turbulent United sides.

Kobbie Mainoo fits Carrick’s philosophy almost perfectly. Comfortable receiving under pressure, tactically intelligent and positionally disciplined, Mainoo would likely be central to build-up phases, either as the deeper of a double pivot or as the single anchor in games where United expect to dominate. Carrick values midfielders who sense danger early rather than react late.

Further forward, Benjamin Sesko’s profile suggests a focal point used to stretch defences vertically. Carrick’s Middlesbrough sides benefited from a striker who could pin centre-backs and open space for runners, rather than dropping constantly into midfield.

Getty Images

That could suit Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo, both of whom thrive attacking channels from wider or second-striker positions, rather than being fixed touchline wingers.

Amad Diallo, meanwhile, looks like a Carrick player. Intelligent movement, technical security and an ability to combine in tight spaces align with the kind of right-sided playmaker Carrick previously trusted to maintain structure without neutering creativity.

This is unlikely to be a revolution. Carrick is not a chaos agent or a philosophical zealot. What United can expect is something quieter: clearer spacing, fewer transitional messes and a belief that good structure gives good players room to breathe. For a caretaker, that may be exactly the point.

How to watch the Premier League in Canada

Soccer fans in Canada can watch every Premier League match during the 2025-26 season on DAZN.

With Fubo Sports on DAZN, Canadians can catch Premier League action as well as Serie A. Additionally, DAZN is the home of the UEFA Champions League, UEFA Europa League, UEFA Conference League, Bundesliga, and more.

For pricing information and to sign up to watch, click here.