Error code: %{errorCode}
Why was Bill Belichick snubbed by Hall of Fame voters in his first year of eligibility?
Bill Belichick did not earn first-ballot induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, and the news has created a backlash across the league.
His head coaching record leaves no room for debate. Six Super Bowl rings as head coach of the New England Patriots, two rings as DC of the New York Giants, and a legacy that reshaped how the NFL measures sustained success.
Why, then, was Belichick, who has won as many Vince Lombardi Trophies as Hall of Fame coaches such as Don Shula, Tom Landry, and Bill Parcells put together, overlooked in his first year of eligibility?
Here’s how we see the factors that likely forced Belichick to wait.
Watch Super Bowl LX live on DAZN for only 99p
DAZN’s latest Game Pass deal gives you complete access to Super Bowl LX, alongside full replays of every playoff and regular season game, for just £0.99.
The offer arrives ahead of the ultimate showdown, as Drake Maye’s New England Patriots prepare to face the Seattle Seahawks’ relentless defense with the Lombardi Trophy on the line.
In addition to every game, live or on demand, Game Pass also provides access to RedZone, NFL Network, and DAZN’s weekly original shows, including Downs 2 Business, Kittle Things, and X's & O's coaching breakdown.
Click here for more information and to sign up.
A numbers game
To be enshrined, Belichick needed at least 40 of the 50 votes from the Hall of Fame panel. ESPN reported on Tuesday that Belichick failed to reach that mark.
Hall of Fame voters are limited to selecting five modern-era candidates per class. In Belichick’s first year of eligibility, the ballot was crowded, forcing selectors into strategic decisions.
It's possible that voters opted for candidates whom they feared might not survive another cycle. Some reports suggest voters withheld support from Belichick, confident that he would eventually get in without needing immediate backing.
Recency bias
As undeniably successful as Belichick’s tenure was with the Patriots, his final years were marked by declining results, roster turnover, and quarterback instability - points that may remain fresh in voters’ minds.
History suggests that a little distance often helps. With time, the totality of Belichick’s career will probably stand out more clearly.
Internal politics?
Unlike Landry and Shula, who were enshrined on their first attempt, Belichick was embroiled in two scandals during his time with the Patriots.
In 2007, Belichick was fined for his involvement in the 'Spygate' controversy. And in 2015, as part of the 'Deflategate' scandal, the Patriots were fined following an investigation that found they deflated footballs. Picks were forfeited in both cases.
Unverified reports suggest some voters felt Belichick should have to wait a year as atonement for his involvement.
Polian, accused in the tweet above, reportedly denied that claim.
Amid calls for voters to justify their votes, a spokesperson for the Hall of Fame stated: "The Pro Football Hall of Fame does not comment on the voting of the Selection Committee and awaits the unveiling of the Class of 2026 at 'NFL Honors' on Feb. 5 in San Francisco."
The backlash
Several prominent figures in the NFL and beyond have weighed in on the argument, including Hall of Fame voter Mike Sando, who provided a detailed breakdown of his stance.
Former players also shared their views.
Â
The backlash even extended beyond football.
Final thoughts
Belichick’s place in football history isn’t up for debate, not really. He's undeniably one of, if not the best, head coaches in the history of the sport, and the standard he set still looms over the league.
This outcome says far more about the Hall of Fame process than it does about Belichick himself. History has a way of smoothing out these moments. And first-ballot or not, it's a case of when, not if, he is enshrined in Canton.
Watch López vs. Stevenson only on DAZN PPV
Teofimo López and Shakur Stevenson headline the Ring VI fight night in New York, exclusively on DAZN PPV, on January 31, 2026.
Purchase as a one-off PPV, or get included at no extra cost with a DAZN Ultimate Tier subscription, which includes a minimum of 12 PPV events per year, plus another 185 fight nights. Monthly and annual options available.
Sign up for Ultimate for £22.99 in the UK / $44.99 in the U.S. More details here.
