The perils of replacing Pep: why Man City's next manager faces an unenviable task

There are dream jobs in football and then there are poisoned chalices disguised as dream jobs. Taking over at Manchester City after Pep Guardiola might fall into the latter category.

With Enzo Maresca widely expected to inherit the Etihad dugout following Guardiola’s emotional farewell, the temptation is to frame the appointment as seamless succession.

A trusted disciple replacing the master. Continuity over revolution. Familiarity over risk. But football history has a nasty habit of exposing how impossible it is to replace generational figures, even when clubs convince themselves otherwise.

For evidence, Maresca needs only glance across Manchester.

DAZN/FIFA

When Sir Alex Ferguson left Manchester United in 2013, the assumption was that the machine would keep humming. The infrastructure remained, the revenue remained, the winning culture remained. What disappeared was the force of personality capable of holding the whole thing together.

David Moyes inherited title winners and quickly looked overwhelmed by the shadow looming over Old Trafford. More than a decade later, United are still trying to escape Ferguson’s gravitational pull.

Guardiola’s imprint on City runs just as deep. He has not merely coached the club; he has re-engineered it in his own image. Recruitment, academy development, sports science, tactical structure, transfer profiles and even the rhythm of how City play football have revolved around him for a decade.

His departure is not just the loss of a manager. It is the removal of the central operating system.

And unlike Ferguson’s final title-winning United side, Maresca would not be inheriting champions at the peak of their powers.

City’s 2025-26 campaign ended with silverware, but also with unmistakable signs of erosion. The midfield legs that once suffocated opponents no longer look inexhaustible. The aura of inevitability has faded. Too often this season, City looked like a magnificent side trying to outrun time itself.

@ManCity

The departure of Bernardo Silva only sharpens that sense of transition. Silva has been one of the defining Guardiola players: technically immaculate, tactically intelligent and physically relentless. Replacing his creativity is difficult enough; replacing his understanding of Guardiola’s positional game may be impossible.

There is major surgery required across this squad. The long-term future of several senior players feels uncertain. City spent heavily on regeneration over the last two years, but Maresca would still inherit a side awkwardly positioned between eras: not old enough for total rebuild language, not young enough to avoid it.

Then comes the small matter of the 115 charges hanging over the club.

Whatever the eventual outcome, the case has become an unavoidable cloud over City’s future planning. Rival fans joke that Guardiola has timed his exit perfectly, while social media is already awash with gallows humour about what awaits his successor.

But for Maresca, the uncertainty is real. Potential sanctions, reputational damage and years of scrutiny would create pressure that extends far beyond results on the pitch.

Getty Images

And that is the cruellest part of this job. Even success may not be enough.

If Maresca wins one Premier League title in his first three seasons, it will be considered a disappointment because Guardiola made four in a row feel normal. If City fall short in Europe, comparisons will be immediate.

Every tactical tweak will be judged against the original blueprint. Every dropped point will prompt questions about why Guardiola’s methods are no longer working under Guardiola-lite.

Perhaps Maresca succeeds brilliantly. Perhaps continuity really is the smartest path available. But replacing one of the greatest managers football has ever seen is not an opportunity without peril. It is a test of endurance, authority and reinvention.

Just ask Manchester United how easy life after a legend can be.

 

Watch World Cup archive, highlights, and documentaries for FREE on DAZN

DAZN is the home of FIFA+ , a vast library of football on-demand content including World Cup archive, iconic documentaries, player profiles, live matches, and both full match replays and highlights.

Watch it all for FREE on DAZN on smart TVs, phones, tablets, streaming devices, games consoles, and web browsers.

FIFA+ includes:

• FIFA World Cup archive - full match replays of all matches from Brazil 1970 to Qatar 2022
• World Cup goals - the best goals from each tournament; every goal from every nation from every tournament
• Original documentaries - including Mo: A Global Icon; Golden Boot: The Documentary; After Diego
• Icons of the game - From Pelé to Cristiano Ronaldo
• Behind-the-scenes content
• Live matches from around the world